Oct 12, 2015 14:56
8 yrs ago
2 viewers *
Spanish term

tuve mucha complicidad con ella

Spanish to English Art/Literary General / Conversation / Greetings / Letters In A Novel
Contexto (the "las" refers to the stars, which she has personified in this passage):

Mientras las contemplaba, Kito se acurrucaba debajo de la silla de madera en la que antaño tu padre se había sentado junto a Daren aquellas noches previas a la guerra y en la que yo me encontraba para acompañar a la soledad. Desde mi primera noche en esta plantación, tuve mucha complicidad con ella.

Gracias,

Barbara

Discussion

@Neil Thank you, Neil.
Neil Ashby Oct 13, 2015:
@ Adoración ;@) ... either way I think you have a good point re: the whole paragraph refers to the wooden chair...
@Neil I know, Neil. Muriel did. I apologise for any confusion.
Neil Ashby Oct 13, 2015:
@ Adoración I never thought that "ella" ever referred to the star.
Muriel Vasconcellos Oct 13, 2015:
@Adoración I see it now.
Muriel & Neil I don't think it can be the star that "ella" is referring to, as the only reference to the stars in the extract is in plural; there is no mention of a single star, as far as I can see.

There may be something else outside this given context that clarifies what "ella" may be referring to. Otherwise, it has to be either the chair or her loneliness.

It may well be that "ella" refers to "la soledad", but the reason why I think it is more likely to refer to the chair is that this seems to be the "protagonist" in the whole extract:

It is where she would sit to look at the stars;
Kito would curl up beneath it (giving the impression that the child felt protected by the chair);
it is the chair where her husband used to sit;
it is where she would sit to accompany her loneliness (because it is where her husband used to sit).
Neil Ashby Oct 13, 2015:
Muriel doesn't the LA you mention refer to the seat (silla de madera)?

Also I think Franglish is right about ELLA = soledad,

"....and in which I found myself to accompany my loneliness. From my first night at that plantation, solitude became my soulmate.
Muriel Vasconcellos Oct 13, 2015:
I think it's the star Notice that she says "en LA que yo me encontraba para acompañar a la soledad."
franglish Oct 12, 2015:
ella refers to la soledad.

Proposed translations

13 hrs
Selected

I have had a special bond with it

I think it's a little more than an attachment, though that idea is good, too.

I'd like to say 'her' to personalize it more, but Kito could be masculine. But we're stuck with ' it' because the author is using "ella" to refer to the feminine word "estrella"
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
10 mins

they became my confidants.

I believe is "they," since the paraghraph starts with "mientras las contemplaba." So the last word would be "ellas."
Something went wrong...
+1
42 mins

affinity/ got on very well

Talking ella to be la soledad I woud say affinity:
A Study on Exploring People's Affinity for Solitude
oaktrust.library.tamu.edu/handle/1969.1/149243
by S LEE - ‎2013 - ‎Related articles
This study sought to investigate solitude as a phenomenon. People's affinity for solitude and the antecedents of affinity for solitude were of crucial interest to the .
If talking about people perhaps the second option.
Peer comment(s):

agree franglish : "...I felt a great affinity with it."
27 mins
Something went wrong...
+4
1 hr

I felt very attached to it

I actually think "ella" refers to the wooden chair.
Note from asker:
That's the way I read it now, too. Thanks.
Peer comment(s):

agree Susan Andrew : Yes, I think ella refers to the chair too.
2 hrs
Thank you, Susan.
agree Wendy Streitparth
3 hrs
Thank you, Wendy.
agree Yvonne Gallagher : so do I
7 hrs
Thank you, Gallagy.
agree Muriel Vasconcellos
18 hrs
Thank you, Muriel.
Something went wrong...
4 hrs

we were inseparable

this way you don't need to know who or what "ella" is
Something went wrong...
17 hrs

solitude became my soulmate

"beneath the wooden chair where your father used to sit alongside Daren in those evenings before the war and in which I found myself to accompany my loneliness. From my first night at that plantation, solitude became my soulmate."
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search